| 2025 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 0 | 1 | .000 | 5th | 15th | |
| 2024 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 74 | 88 | .457 | 5th | 12th | |
| 2023 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 89 | 73 | .549 | 3rd | 5th | Lost Wild Card Series |
| 2022 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 92 | 70 | .568 | 2nd | 4th | Lost Wild Card Series |
| 2021 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 91 | 71 | .562 | 4th | 6th | |
| 2020 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 32 | 28 | .533 | 3rd | 8th | Lost Wild Card Series |
| 2019 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 67 | 95 | .414 | 4th | 12th | |
| 2018 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 73 | 89 | .451 | 4th | 10th | |
| 2017 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 76 | 86 | .469 | 4th | 11th | |
| 2016 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 89 | 73 | .549 | 3rd | 5th | Lost League Championship Series |
| 2015 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 93 | 69 | .574 | 1st | 2nd | Lost League Championship Series |
| 2014 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 83 | 79 | .512 | 3rd | 9th | |
| 2013 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 74 | 88 | .457 | 5th | 11th | |
| 2012 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 73 | 89 | .451 | 4th | 10th | |
| 2011 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 81 | 81 | .500 | 4th | 7th | |
| 2010 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 85 | 77 | .525 | 4th | 7th | |
| 2009 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 75 | 87 | .463 | 4th | 11th | |
| 2008 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 86 | 76 | .531 | 4th | 7th | |
| 2007 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 83 | 79 | .512 | 3rd | 7th | |
| 2006 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 87 | 75 | .537 | 2nd | 7th | |
| 2005 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 80 | 82 | .494 | 3rd | 8th | |
| 2004 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 67 | 94 | .416 | 5th | 12th | |
| 2003 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 86 | 76 | .531 | 3rd | 7th | |
| 2002 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 78 | 84 | .481 | 3rd | 8th | |
| 2001 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 80 | 82 | .494 | 3rd | 8th | |
| 2000 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 83 | 79 | .512 | 3rd | 7th | |
| 1999 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 84 | 78 | .519 | 3rd | 6th | |
| 1998 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 88 | 74 | .543 | 3rd | 5th | |
| 1997 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 76 | 86 | .469 | 5th | 11th | |
| 1996 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 74 | 88 | .457 | 4th | 12th | |
| 1995 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 56 | 88 | .389 | 5th | 14th | |
| 1994 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 55 | 60 | .478 | 3rd | 6th | |
🏆 | 1993 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 95 | 67 | .586 | 1st | 1st | Won World Series |
🏆 | 1992 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 96 | 66 | .593 | 1st | 2nd | Won World Series |
| 1991 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 91 | 71 | .562 | 1st | 2nd | Lost League Championship Series |
| 1990 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 86 | 76 | .531 | 2nd | 4th | |
| 1989 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 89 | 73 | .549 | 1st | 4th | Lost League Championship Series |
| 1988 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 87 | 75 | .537 | 3rd | 6th | |
| 1987 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 96 | 66 | .593 | 2nd | 2nd | |
| 1986 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 86 | 76 | .531 | 4th | 6th | |
| 1985 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 99 | 62 | .615 | 1st | 1st | Lost League Championship Series |
| 1984 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 89 | 73 | .549 | 2nd | 2nd | |
| 1983 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 89 | 73 | .549 | 4th | 5th | |
| 1982 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 78 | 84 | .481 | 6th | 10th | |
| 1981 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 37 | 69 | .349 | 7th | 14th | |
| 1980 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 67 | 95 | .414 | 7th | 12th | |
| 1979 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 53 | 109 | .327 | 7th | 14th | |
| 1978 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 59 | 102 | .366 | 7th | 13th | |
| 1977 | AL | Toronto Blue Jays | 54 | 107 | .335 | 7th | 14th | |