Brian Deane has tallied the most career goals by a Sheffield United player in the Premier League, with 15 goals.

	NAME	G	M	MIN	START	G/M	A	G+A	PK	FK	SH	SOT	WOOD	TCH	TCH-BOX	OFF
1	Brian Deane B. Deane	15	41	3,676	41	0.37	10	25	1
2	Oliver McBurnie O. McBurnie	13	80	4,721	51	0.16	3	16	2	0	113	55	3	2,273	241	12
3	Adrian Littlejohn A. Littlejohn	11	46	2,780	30	0.24	3	14	0
4	David McGoldrick D. McGoldrick	10	63	4,226	50	0.16	3	13	0	0	116	44	1	2,372	158	29
5	Dane Whitehouse D. Whitehouse	10	52	4,230	49	0.19	8	18	3
6	Jostein Flo J. Flo	9	33	2,896	32	0.27	4	13	0
7	Rob Hulse R. Hulse	8	29	2,457	28	0.28	1	9	0
8	Ben Brereton Díaz B. Brereton Díaz	6	14	1,110	14	0.43	1	7	1	0	35	19	1	438	60	10
9	Billy Sharp B. Sharp	6	41	1,775	17	0.15	2	8	2	0	25	13	1	605	92	23
10	Lys Mousset L. Mousset	6	41	1,521	13	0.15	4	10	0	0	41	11	1	599	92	21
11	Glyn Hodges G. Hodges	6	62	4,468	47	0.10	10	16	0
12	Paul Rogers P. Rogers	6	52	4,434	50	0.12	1	7	0
13	Jayden Bogle J. Bogle	5	50	3,901	44	0.10	0	5	0	0	49	18	0	2,063	97	5
14	John Fleck J. Fleck	5	65	5,182	58	0.08	4	9	0	0	48	16	1	3,067	68	2
15	John Lundstram J. Lundstram	5	62	4,487	49	0.08	5	10	0	0	64	16	1	2,881	77	8
16	Jon Stead J. Stead	5	14	1,064	12	0.36	0	5	0
17	Nathan Blake N. Blake	5	12	724	7	0.42	0	5	0
18	Alan Cork A. Cork	5	46	2,025	18	0.11	1	6	0
19	Brian Gayle B. Gayle	5	44	3,960	44	0.11	4	9	0
20	Cameron Archer C. Archer	4	29	1,835	21	0.14	1	5	0	0	42	11	1	652	81	13
21	Gustavo Hamer G. Hamer	4	36	2,925	34	0.11	6	10	0	0	49	15	0	1,471	48	6
22	Phil Jagielka P. Jagielka	4	54	4,186	46	0.07	1	5	2
23	Willie Falconer W. Falconer	4	23	1,844	21	0.17	1	5	0
24	Franz Carr F. Carr	4	18	1,494	18	0.22	2	6	0
25	James Mcatee J. Mcatee	3	30	1,827	20	0.10	3	6	1	0	26	9	0	883	72	1